Once again union leaders roll the dice hoping the NLRB will save them. The Wall Street Journal explains.
Boeing’s eight-year contract offer included a 1% wage increase every other year starting in 2016 on top of annual cost-of-living increases. Pension accruals would be frozen, and traditional defined-benefit plans would be replaced with 401(k) accounts with a generous employer match.
In return for these changes, Boeing offered to sweeten the basic pension benefit multiplier to $95 per month from $85, yielding an additional $2,400 annually for a new retiree with 20 years of service. Upon approving the contract, workers would also receive a $10,000 signing bonus and an effective job guarantee for the next two decades.
These pay and benefit modifications would save Boeing about $2 billion over the eight-year contract and help the company compete with the Airbus A350 that has been a hot ticket with international carriers. Settling the contract in advance of the current labor agreement’s expiration in 2016 would also assuage concerns about future strikes, which contributed to the company’s 2009 decision to build its 787 Dreamliner in right-to-work North Charleston, South Carolina.
Boeing warned the union that rejecting the contract could jeopardize 20,000 jobs. Local machinist president Tom Wroblewski responded by saying this risk is worth taking to preserve the union’s “sacred” traditional pension, though a pension won’t amount to much if workers lose their jobs.
Perhaps the machinists figure they can count on intervention once again by the National Labor Relations Board. After Boeing announced production of its 787 in South Carolina, the labor board filed charges against Boeing for illegal retaliation. The agency’s acting general counsel Lafe Solomon withdrew the charges in 2011 only after Boeing agreed to generous wage increases and to build its new 737 MAX in Washington. The NLRB’s new general counsel is longtime labor friend Richard Griffin.
But relying on politics to save jobs is risky business in a world of competition. Boeing executives are trying to avoid becoming the next GM or U.S. Steel and they’ll build aircraft elsewhere if the Seattle union stays trapped in a nostalgic past of lifetime guarantees and 30-year pensions. Politicians may pander to unions but they also can’t defy business reality.
Latest posts by E.J. Smith - Your Survival Guy (see all)
- My March Rage Gauge: Take Inventory of Your Investment Life - February 22, 2019
- Americans Want to Leave Their High Tax States - February 21, 2019
- National Right to Work Could Help States That Can’t Help Themselves - February 20, 2019