Richardcyoung.com

The Online Home of Author and Investor, Dick Young

  • Home
  • How We Are Different
  • About Us
    • Foundation Principles
    • Contributors
  • Investing
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
  • Your Survival Guy
  • The Great Reset
  • COVID-19
  • My Rifles
  • Dividends and Compounding
  • Your Security
  • The Swiss Way
  • Dick Young
  • Debbie Young
  • Key West
  • Paris
  • Dick’s R&B Top 100
  • Liberty & Freedom Map
  • Your Health
  • Ron Paul
  • Bank Credit & Money
  • Dick Young’s Safe America
  • Your Survival Guy’s Super States
  • Critical Race Theory
  • NNT & Cholesterol
  • Work to Make Money/Invest to Save Money

Impeachment – a Political Remedy, Not a Legal One

October 25, 2019 By Debbie Young

President Donald J. Trump meets with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Congressional leadership Wednesday, Oct. 16, 2019, in the Cabinet Room of the White House. (Official White House Photo by Shealah Craighead)

Originally posted on October 21, 2019.

If Trump’s missteps warrant an impeachable offense, why are Democrats not voting to conduct the impeachment inquiry? Why are they not proudly holding hearings in public with due process, rather than behind closed doors with selective leaking?

In Andrew McCarthy’s book, Faithless Execution, he deals with the thesis that because the Framers feared an agglomeration of power in the presidency they were creating, they endowed Congress with significant checks on the executive. “The ultimate one was impeachment,” which was to be reserved for truly abominable misconduct.

(The Framers) understood that governance would involve tussles between the political branches and episodes of overreach — whether out of incompetence, malevolence, or urgency — for which the extraordinary impeachment remedy would be gross overkill. Routine disputes involving the propensities of both the legislature and the executive to act outside their authorities would be handled by lesser remedies. Congress, most importantly, was given the power of the purse and significant power over executive agencies (to create them, to limit their authority, and, in the Senate’s case, to approve their leaders).

Mr. McCarthy argues in Faithless Execution that this system has broken down, and he fears there are no repairs on the horizon.

The Framers naturally thought congressional control of the executive budget would obviate the need to resort to impeachment. Lawmakers could defund dubious executive initiatives and withhold funds necessary to carry out the president’s priorities; this would pressure the executive branch to comply with statutes as well as congressional demands for information and policy modification. The ultimate question of a president’s fitness would be left to the sovereign — the American people, exercising the franchise.

With Donald Trump in office and impeachment in play, that adage is repeated so often it seems platitudinous. But it states a vital truth: The mere existence of misconduct that the House might judge impeachable does not mean the Senate — by a two-thirds supermajority — would remove a president over it. That fact, coupled with the inherent societal discord impeachment is bound to cause, has historically discouraged the House from commencing impeachment inquiries, even for arguably impeachable offenses.

The upshot is that impeachment can never be successfully invoked — in the sense of both filing articles of impeachment and ousting the president from power — absent a public consensus, cutting across partisan lines, that a president needs to be removed. Only such a consensus would move members of the House and Senate, who must face voters. Therefore, a public political case has to be made for impeachment. It is not enough to show that a president has overstepped here or there. The public must be convinced that these excesses are so serious, so indicative of unfitness, that it is worth putting the country through the trauma of removing the chief executive.

Impeachment – the Ultimate Power

Moreover, we are just one year out from an election in which, if Trump is as bad as Democrats say, the voters will remove him. Yet, Trump’s approval rating hovers at around 43 percent, close to what Obama’s was a year before his reelection. Trump could certainly lose, but he stands a decent chance of being reelected. Hence far from a strong consensus for his removal, there will be zealous protest against impeachment by a significant segment of the public.

Consequently, the Republican-controlled Senate will swiftly reject the House Democrats’ impeachment articles as a partisan stunt — as precisely the abuse of power the Framers feared. And woe betide the next Democrat president seeking the bipartisan cooperation needed to govern.

A Gross Imbalance in the Political Branches

Our constitutional system will be damaged because impeachment will be discredited. That will not make it any less indispensable than Madison judged it to be. Yet its invocation will be even less likely in some grievous future instance, when a presidential abuse of power actually does imperil the nation. We will have a virtually omnipotent president. As a practical matter, there will be no viable congressional check — no impeachment, no power of the purse — to rein the president in. The powers of the competing political branches will be in gross imbalance, making functional separation of powers impossible.

As the Framers would tell us, that is not a prescription for the preservation of liberty.

More from Andrew McCarthy here.

Andrew C. McCarthy: Faithless Execution: Building a Political Case for Obama’s Impeachment

If you’re willing to fight for Main Street America, click here to sign up for the Richardcyoung.com free weekly email.

Related Posts

  • Impeachment – a Simple Way to Discredit Trump?
  • Impeachment – What Is the Underlying Crime?
  • The Impeachment Shop of Horrors
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Debbie Young
Debbie, editor-in-chief of Richardcyoung.com, has been associate editor of Dick Young’s investment strategy reports for over three decades. When not in Key West, Debbie spends her free time researching and writing in and about Paris and Burgundy, France, cooking on her AGA Cooker, driving her Porsche Boxter S through Vermont and Maine, and practicing yoga.
Latest posts by Debbie Young (see all)
  • Breaking News: House Election Update - July 1, 2022
  • Should You Believe Ms. Hutchinson? - June 30, 2022
  • An Assault on America’s Central Core - June 29, 2022

Dick Young’s Must Reads

  • U.S. Survival AR-7
  • Soros’s Open Society Foundation, Charles Koch Team Up
  • Protection While Traveling in France
  • Does Big Government Create Poverty?
  • Richard Feynman Solved the Space Shuttle Disaster Mystery
  • The County Sheriff: America’s Last Hope
  • Are You Prepared to Run Out of Water?
  • The Three Best Retirement Decisions I Ever Made
  • America’s Number One Patriot: Naples Florida’s Alfie Oakes
  • Your Survival Guy’s 2022 Super States: #1 New Hampshire

Our Most Popular Posts

  • FOOD SHORTAGE: Not "If," But "How Bad?"
  • One Surprising Thing You Should Know About Private Jets
  • Saudi Oil Is Different from U.S. Oil?
  • Good News for the 2nd Amendment
  • Your Survival Guy in Paris: Awakened from His Slumber, “Dad, I’m Going to London”
  • FLORIDA DODGED A BULLET: Elected Superb DeSantis Over Unstable Gillum
  • The Most Controversial Restaurant in Paris?
  • 10th AMENDMENT: Dobbs Decision a Win for States' Rights
  • What Just Happened? Fixing Its Historic Mistake
  • For Investors Who Want to Stop Worrying About a Market Crash

Disclosure

RSS Youngresearch.com

  • Happy Independence Day
  • Even Without Food and Gas, Inflation is Soaring
  • Despite Inflation, Best Year Ever for Vacation Demand
  • Time to Save, Troubles Dining Out, and Intelligence on Yellowstone
  • Purchases of Gaming Chips for Crypto Mining Tailing Off
  • RURAL RENAISSANCE: America Finds the Country Again
  • Are Google, Amazon, and Microsoft About to Crash This Specialized Real Estate Market?
  • Why Work When Taxes Take It All?
  • Regulators’ Bungled Attempts to Cut Emissions Drove Oil Prices Higher
  • Your Survival Guy in Paris: Awakened from His Slumber, “Dad, I’m Going to London”

Happy Independence Day

For Investors Who Want to Stop Worrying About a Market Crash

Breaking News: House Election Update

WATCH: New York Governor Melts Down When Asked for Facts

Florida Is a Refresher Course in American Greatness

Should You Believe Ms. Hutchinson?

Copyright © 2022 | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Dick Young | Archives