Richardcyoung.com

The Online Home of Author and Investor, Dick Young

  • Home
  • How We Are Different
  • About Us
    • Foundation Principles
    • Contributors
  • Investing
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
  • Your Survival Guy
  • The Great Reset
  • COVID-19
  • My Rifles
  • Dividends and Compounding
  • Your Security
  • The Swiss Way
  • Dick Young
  • Debbie Young
  • Key West
  • Paris
  • Dick’s R&B Top 100
  • Liberty & Freedom Map
  • Bank Credit & Money
  • Your Survival Guy’s Super States
  • NNT & Cholesterol
  • Work to Make Money/Invest to Save Money
  • Your Health
  • Ron Paul
  • US Treasury Yield Curve: My Favorite Investor Tool

Let the Lockdown End, County by County

April 27, 2020 By David Franke

By Malachy666 @ Shutterstock.com

Pandemic Report No. 5

Grassroots protests are multiplying against the draconian stay-at-home orders, and every day brings new announcements of states ending parts of their lockdowns.  The challenge is to do it intelligently to avoid a second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Geographically, the way to do that is to end the lockdowns on a county-by-county basis, as I will advocate in this report.

Government has responded to this crisis as it always does:  Fail to prepare before a crisis strikes, then try to ignore or minimize the threat in its early stages, then over-react.  This is true of both broad political alignments, the Left and the Right, of both major political parties, and of government at all levels—federal, state, and local.

The over-reaction has been in the form of essentially a national lockdown, covering 95% of the population and causing the most dramatic and rapid crippling of the American economy in our nation’s history.  We have treated the entire nation as if it is New York and New Jersey, the states hardest hit by the pandemic.  The mainstream media are mostly headquartered in New York and Washington, and are so parochial in their social and political biases that they eagerly buy into this viewpoint.  They are expatriates in their own land, insulated from and contemptuous of the viewpoints of their fellow citizens outside that Washington-New York corridor.

In its broadest form, we have seen America divided—politically and culturally—between the East and West Coasts and the Heartland.  While cultural influences tend to flow from west to east, politically the movement is usually from the east to the west, and the pandemic has solidified the dominance of the East Coast’s Washington-New York corridor.  But the natives in between the coasts and south of Washington are getting restless.

Geographically, America is a huge continental nation, and its demographic, cultural, and political mosaics are just as varied.  To demonstrate the relevance of those differences to the coronavirus pandemic, let’s look at the five states most dramatically different from New York and New Jersey during this crisis.

The 5 Heartland States without a Lockdown

Five states in the Heartland have had no statewide lockdown and no metropolitan lockdowns—North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Iowa, and Arkansas.  And why should they be governed by the same rules as New York and New Jersey?  They are as different in their COVID-19 death rates as they are in their population density.

New York and New Jersey have had 22,904 reported coronavirus deaths as of April 25.  The five no-lockdown states have had a combined total of 261 deaths.

We have seen that this pandemic strikes hard at dense urban areas.  That’s true not only in New York but also in cities such as Detroit and New Orleans.  These five Heartland states have no big cities comparable to those metropolitan areas.  Why should they be subject to rules that treat them as if they were the same?

Indeed, even within these five Heartland states a substantial portion of their deaths are concentrated in their relatively large cities.  In Iowa, half of the deaths occur in just two of the state’s 99 counties—Linn County (Cedar Rapids) and Polk County (Des Moines).  And in Nebraska, 73% of the state’s deaths are in just two of that state’s 93 counties—Douglas County (Omaha) and Hall County (Grand Island).

This is why I have come to the conclusion that coronavirus restrictions should be determined on a county-by-county basis.  The variations within each state are as great as the differences between the East and West Coasts and the Heartland.  The folks in rural areas have even less reason to be restricted in their movements than the people in moderately-sized cities.

By the way, even in these 5 Heartland states there are some restrictions, just no statewide stay-in-place lockdowns.  South Dakota has no statewide directives at all and is the only state in the nation, far as I can determine, where the restaurants and bars have been allowed to stay open for dine-in customers.  But even there the schools are closed.

The Other 43 States

In between these extremes of New York-New Jersey and the 5 Heartland states are the other 43 states.  Seven states have no statewide lockdown but cities within them have shelter-in-place rules: Wyoming, Utah, Texas, Oklahoma, Missouri, Alabama, and South Carolina.  The conditions within all 50 states—even New York and New Jersey—are so varied that the county-by-county rule should apply in all of them.

For example, the state in which I reside, Virginia, has 448 deaths from the virus.  That places it somewhere between the two extremes I’ve used in my example.  But Virginia has 95 counties and 38 independent cities, and they are vastly different in how the pandemic has affected them.

Of those 448 deaths, 175 (39% of the statewide total) have occurred in the Northern Virginia suburbs of Washington, D.C. (known as NOVA).  Another 121 deaths (27% of the statewide total) have occurred in the Richmond area.  Together these two urban areas account for two-thirds of all the reported COVID-19 deaths in Virginia.

In the area of the state where I reside—the northern Shenandoah Valley—there thankfully have been no recorded deaths so far.  Yet we are governed by the same statewide directives that apply to NOVA and Richmond.  This is patently unjust and makes no sense.

You can do the math as it applies to your state and locality.  The New York Times compiles constantly updated statistics.  Scroll down to “Cases and deaths by state and county.”

Powerful forces want a nationwide lockdown that ignores these differences between states and within each state.  Bill Gates, for example, argues that “because people can travel across state lines, so can the virus.  The country’s leaders need to be clear: Shutdown anywhere means shutdown everywhere.”

But a national rule is not necessary.  If states perceive a threat from people fleeing to them from other states, they can enact their own travel restrictions.  As an extreme example, Texas has placed 14-day quarantines on air travelers flying to Texas from New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, California, Louisiana, Washington, Atlanta, Chicago, Detroit, and Miami.  (“Don’t mess with Texas” is the state’s motto.  Obviously they mean it.)

A fundamental basis for safeguarding liberty in America is to keep political power as close to the people as possible.  This is especially true with regard to the coronavirus pandemic, where a federal mandate is unwarranted and even state directives can be grossly unfair.  As much as possible, we should let the people in each of America’s more than 3,000 counties decide how and when to restrict activities while fighting the virus.   

My Previous Articles on the Coronavirus Pandemic

  • How Big of a Threat Is the Coronavirus? (March 26)
  • How Bad Has the Pandemic Been? How Bad Will It Be? (April 6)
  • An Economic Shutdown Based On…What? (April 15)
  • Is Sweden’s Problem Coronavirus or Immigration?  (April 21)

And see all my articles in this pandemic series.

Related Posts

  • Florida Keys Monroe County Coronavirus Report
  • Orange County Choppers takes on CNG build
  • Sanders & Trump: How Newport County Voted in RI Primary
  • Greetings from Key West During Lockdown
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
David Franke
David Franke was one of the founders of the conservative movement in the late 1950s and early 1960s, starting his media career at Human Events and National Review (editorial assistant to William F. Buckley Jr.).His articles have appeared in the New York Times, Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, Esquire, and many other publications.His books have included Safe Places, The Torture Doctor, Richard C. Young’s Financial Armadillo Strategy (as co-author to Dick Young), and America’s Right Turn (with Richard A. Viguerie).He was Senior Editor of Silver & Gold Report in the 1980s, and served as the writer/editor of John Naisbitt’s Trend Letter in the 1990s.A native Texan, David now lives in Virginia’s beautiful Shenandoah Valley.
Latest posts by David Franke (see all)
  • Will Expats Decide the Election? - October 21, 2020
  • Good Satire is Hard to Find - October 20, 2020
  • My Fearless Election Prediction - October 19, 2020

Dick Young’s Must Reads

  • You May Be Surprised by America’s “Least Woke City”
  • What to Do about China?
  • Your Best State on Guns, Plus the 8th Wonder of the World
  • “I’ve Got Guys Buying Guns/Ammo for Me All Through the Night.”
  • The Three Best Retirement Decisions I Ever Made
  • YOU DESERVE FREEDOM: Your Hard Work Will Make It Happen
  • Ron Paul: “Freedom and Central Banking Are Not Compatible”
  • The Fed – “Independent” and “Non Political” – Joins The Resistance
  • Escape From the City: You’re Going to Like What You See
  • Progressive Liberalism Has Dragged America near Ruination

Our Most Popular Posts

  • Will Western Tanks Be a Game Changer in Ukraine?
  • Europe Should Protect Itself
  • “I Will Veto Everything They Send Me”
  • Warren Miller: If You Don’t Do It This Year, You’ll Be…
  • US Debt Now Exceeds Annual GDP?
  • How to Fight Wokism Idiocy
  • The Neocon Russia-Hoaxers of Hamilton 68 Must Be Held Accountable
  • Why Don’t These Mayors Seem to Care?
  • What Kind of Life Are You Investing For?
  • SEN. KENNEDY: This Is How to Fix Biden's Border Disaster

Disclosure

RSS Youngresearch.com

  • What Your Survival Guy Invested in Today
  • Your Retirement Life: Adventure Awaits
  • UK Takes Aim at the Cryptocurrency Industry
  • Early Advice from Her Dad on Tipping at Charlie Trotter’s
  • Do You Trust This Rally?
  • Reagan’s America Remembered by Your Survival Guy and More
  • What Happens if the “Fed Put” Is Over for Good?
  • Tom Brady Retires, Again. Should You?
  • What Kind of Life Are You Investing For?
  • Warren Miller: If You Don’t Do It This Year, You’ll Be…

RSS Yoursurvivalguy.com

  • What Your Survival Guy Invested in Today
  • You Invest, They Win: FTX Edition
  • Your Retirement Life: Adventure Awaits
  • Zumwalt-Class Guided Missile Destroyers to Get Hypersonic Weapons
  • Early Advice from Her Dad on Tipping at Charlie Trotter’s
  • Treasury Bonds Ready to Rock and Roll
  • Survive and Thrive February 2023: 4 Life Changing Words: “You Should Try This”
  • Tom Brady Retires, Again. Should You?
  • Reagan’s America Remembered by Your Survival Guy and More
  • America’s Unprecedented Debt Problem

Trump Channeled Pat Buchanan to Win GOP Primary

Hang Tight or Hang Alone

What Your Survival Guy Invested in Today

COVID: Demand Accountability for the World’s Biggest Ponzi Schemers

Will Biden Start Wars with Both Russia and China?

Price Controls Won’t Work in Any Country

Copyright © 2023 | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Dick Young | Archives