Richardcyoung.com

The Online Home of Author and Investor, Dick Young

  • Home
  • How We Are Different
  • About Us
    • Foundation Principles
    • Contributors
  • Investing
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
  • Your Survival Guy
  • The Great Reset
  • COVID-19
  • My Rifles
  • Dividends and Compounding
  • Your Security
  • The Swiss Way
  • Dick Young
  • Debbie Young
  • Key West
  • Paris
  • Dick’s R&B Top 100
  • Liberty & Freedom Map
  • Bank Credit & Money
  • Your Survival Guy’s Super States
  • NNT & Cholesterol
  • Work to Make Money/Invest to Save Money
  • Your Health
  • Ron Paul
  • US Treasury Yield Curve: My Favorite Investor Tool

Was the Soleimani Killing Legal? Yes

January 6, 2020 By The Editors

Secretary of Defense Mark Esper addresses reporters Sunday, Dec. 29, 2019, at Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach, Fla., on the U.S. military defensive strikes against Iranian supported militias in Iraq and Syria. (Official White House Photo by Tia Dufour)

Whether you agree with the decision to kill Qassem Soleimani or not, says Alan Dershowitz, it’s legality is not in question. He writes:

The targeting of Soleimani was more justified, as a matter of law, than the targeting of Osama bin Laden in 2011. The killing of Soleimani was in large part an act of prevention, whereas the killing of bin Laden was primarily an act of retaliation. Would anyone doubt that if Mr. Clinton had succeeded in killing bin Laden before 9/11, as he tried to do, such an action would have been legal under American law? So, too, was it legal for Mr. Trump to order the targeted killing of Soleimani, who was planning to continue his killing spree against Americans.

The killing of Soleimani was also entirely legal under international law. The Quds Force commander was a combatant in uniform who was actively engaged in continuing military and terrorist activities against Americans. The rocket that killed him and a handful of others was carefully calibrated to minimize collateral damage, and the resulting death toll was proportionate to the deaths it may have prevented.

The killing took place in a foreign country, but so did the killing of bin Laden and others who have been targeted. U.S. military and civilian personnel are in Iraq with Baghdad’s approval and have the legal authority to protect Iraqi and American citizens and to neutralize threats to their lives. All the relevant criteria for legality under international law—using authorized and proportionate force to kill a combatant who is engaged in continuing violence—have all been met in this case.

Why then are so many accusing Mr. Trump of acting unlawfully under both domestic and international law? Would the same legal criticism be leveled at Mr. Clinton or Mr. Obama if he had successfully targeted Soleimani? Are the legitimate concerns about the wisdom of the action motivating the baseless criticism of its legality?

Whatever the motivations for trying to find or invent legal objections to the killing of Soleimani, such efforts are dangerous because they could constrain future presidents from taking military actions that are necessary and proper to protect Americans. Let’s continue to debate the wisdom and long-term implications of Mr. Trump’s decision, but let’s not conflate wisdom and policy with legality.

Read more here.

Related Posts

  • Obama’s Nuclear Deal Empowered Soleimani
  • Stop Immigration, Legal and Illegal
  • Those in America Who Benefit Most from a Conflict with Iran
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
The Editors
Latest posts by The Editors (see all)
  • SEN RUBIO: China Balloon Was a Message - February 6, 2023
  • Russia Prepares New Offensive as Biden and NATO Escalate Weapon Deliveries - February 6, 2023
  • TERROR TACTICS: Globalists Use Fear to Demand Compliance - February 3, 2023

Dick Young’s Must Reads

  • The Masters of the Universe Align Themselves with CHINA Using YOUR Money?
  • Sen. Hawley Makes the Case Against U.S.-China Relationship
  • A NEW CONTRACT WITH AMERICA: Rick Scott Finally Gives the GOP Something to Run On
  • ENERGY FREEDOM ACT: Ted Cruz Introduces Bill for Energy Independence
  • Is It All Coming Apart in the Government’s Face?
  • Marry Compound Interest, Divorce Market Timing
  • Boom—Your Life Changes
  • The Case for Individual Stocks: Now More than Ever
  • Americans Fleeing High Tax States for Growth Corridors
  • Warning! Your Survival Guy’s on a Boil Water Advisory

Our Most Popular Posts

  • SEN. KENNEDY: This Is How to Fix Biden's Border Disaster
  • Oh Yes! It Can Get Worse
  • Will Western Tanks Be a Game Changer in Ukraine?
  • What Your Survival Guy Invested in Today
  • You Aren't Getting These Yields from Your Bank Account
  • Europe Should Protect Itself
  • “I Will Veto Everything They Send Me”
  • US Debt Now Exceeds Annual GDP?
  • How to Fight Wokism Idiocy
  • Hang Tight or Hang Alone

Disclosure

RSS Youngresearch.com

  • What Your Survival Guy Invested in Today
  • AI SEARCH WAR BEGINS: Google and Microsoft Join AI Battle
  • Your Retirement Life: Adventure Awaits
  • UK Takes Aim at the Cryptocurrency Industry
  • Early Advice from Her Dad on Tipping at Charlie Trotter’s
  • Do You Trust This Rally?
  • Reagan’s America Remembered by Your Survival Guy and More
  • What Happens if the “Fed Put” Is Over for Good?
  • Tom Brady Retires, Again. Should You?
  • What Kind of Life Are You Investing For?

RSS Yoursurvivalguy.com

  • You Aren’t Getting These Yields from Your Bank Account
  • Bidenflation Has Eaten Up Americans’ Pandemic Savings
  • Dragon Tours Open for Business
  • What Your Survival Guy Invested in Today
  • You Invest, They Win: FTX Edition
  • Your Retirement Life: Adventure Awaits
  • Zumwalt-Class Guided Missile Destroyers to Get Hypersonic Weapons
  • Early Advice from Her Dad on Tipping at Charlie Trotter’s
  • Treasury Bonds Ready to Rock and Roll
  • Survive and Thrive February 2023: 4 Life Changing Words: “You Should Try This”

You Aren’t Getting These Yields from Your Bank Account

Democrats’ Widening Schism

Jimmy Buffett Playing Key West

Whatever You Knew, Dave Hammer Knew More

Dragon Tours Open for Business

Trump Channeled Pat Buchanan to Win GOP Primary

Copyright © 2023 | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Dick Young | Archives