Many developed market politicians are talking up infrastructure spending as a way to generate an economic stimulus, but here in The Wall Street Journal, Phil Gramm pokes some holes in the idea that building highways-to-nowhere will get economies out of their rut. In fact, he likens the push to the same policies that led the world into global recession in 2007-08.
More government spending, particularly for infrastructure projects, is the mantra in Washington and other capitals. But two factors stand in the way. First, the governments of most developed economies are broke. According to their own government figures for 2015, the total public debt of European Union members as a share of GDP is 85%, U.S. debt is 101% and Japanese debt is 229%. Second, the rates of return on infrastructure investments are generally low. As European Central Bank President Mario Draghi said in an interview last October, “There aren’t many public investments with a high rate of return.”
With infrastructure spending so popular and government coffers so empty, the appeal of subverting private wealth to serve government objectives has become even more attractive. The latest scheme to do so is the European Union’s attempt to “incentivize” more insurance investment in public infrastructure as part of its “Solvency II” regulatory regime. In January the EU lowered capital standards for infrastructure investments by as much as 40% but cited no major errors in the old risk model or any new empirical evidence to justify the change. Instead, the EU repeatedly emphasized its need for “€2 trillion in [infrastructure] investment” by 2020.
The U.S. seems set to follow Europe’s lead. The Treasury Department’s new Federal Insurance Office released a report last year encouraging “state insurance regulators to assess the current [risk-based capital] approach and explore appropriate ways to increase incentives for infrastructure investments by insurers.”
Haven’t we seen this movie before? Didn’t lowering capital standards in the mortgage industry have a bad ending? Remember the subprime-mortgage meltdown and the 2007-08 financial crisis?
Private vs Public: Infrastructure Spending
Latest posts by E.J. Smith - Your Survival Guy (see all)
- How Would You Evacuate? Could You? - September 22, 2017
- Should the GOP Cut Taxes Even if it Raises the Deficit? - September 21, 2017
- Shotguns: How to Make them Better - September 20, 2017