Richardcyoung.com

  • Home
  • Debbie Young
  • Jimmy Buffett
  • Key West
  • Your Survival Guy
  • How We Are Different
  • Paris
  • About Us
    • Foundation Principles
    • Contributors
  • Investing
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
  • The Swiss Way
  • My Rifles
  • Dividends and Compounding
  • Your Security
  • Dick Young
  • Dick’s R&B Top 100
  • Liberty & Freedom Map
  • Bank Credit & Money
  • Your Survival Guy’s Super States
  • NNT & Cholesterol
  • Your Health
  • Ron Paul
  • US Treasury Yield Curve: My Favorite Investor Tool
  • Anti-Gun Control
  • Anti-Digital Currency
  • Joel Salatin & Alfie Oakes
  • World Gold Mine Production
  • Fidelity & Wellington Since 1971
  • Hillsdale College
  • Babson College
  • Contact Us

An Easy Solution to Electricity Independence?

March 17, 2022 By Debbie Young

By Sehenswerk @ Shutterstock.com

How should the U.S. handle vulnerability to oil and gas spikes in the world market?

The answer is easy and obvious, explains Francis Menton in the Manhattan Contrarian. Just read almost anything from the American media/academia/environmentalist/Democratic Party society:

Just build more wind turbines and solar arrays until you have enough. These facilities will count as “domestic” electricity generation, and therefore will quickly lead to “energy independence.” What could be easier?

“No amount of incremental wind and solar power can ever provide energy independence,” argues Mr. Menton.

Electricity gets consumed the instant it is generated. Electricity is consumed all the time, and therefore must be generated all the time. Indeed, some of the peak times for electricity consumption occur on winter evenings, when the sun has set, temperatures are very cold, the wind is often completely calm, and the need for energy for light, heat, cooking and more are high. During such times, a combined wind and solar generation system produces zero power. It doesn’t matter if you build a thousand wind turbines and solar panels, or a million, or a billion or a trillion. The output will still be zero.

And calm winter nights are just the most intense piece of the problem. A fully wind/solar generation system, with seemingly plenty of “capacity” to meet peak electricity demand, will also regularly and dramatically underproduce at random critical times throughout a year: for example, on heavily overcast and cold winter days; or on calm and hot summer evenings, when the sun has just set and air conditioning demand is high.

Addressing Storage

To propose energy independence based on wind and solar without fossil fuels, you must, repeat must, address storage. How much is needed? How much would that cost? What loss of energy will be incurred on the turnaround between charge and discharge? Is the cost feasible? How long must the energy be stored between generation and consumption? Do batteries or other storage devices exist that can store energy for such a period without most or all of it draining away? Has there ever been a demonstration of the feasibility of a fossil-fuel-free system based only on wind, solar and storage?

Obvious but Unmentionable in Polite Society

As Mr. Mention explains, a wind and solar generation system will either be:

  1. dependent on fossil fuel backup
  2. dependent on storage for backup
  3. both

If it is taken as given that the whole idea is to move away from fossil fuel backup, then everything comes down to storage. A fossil-fuel-free system based on wind and solar generation is completely useless without sufficient storage to cover all times of insufficient simultaneous generation.

Does advocating more wind and solar facilities as the solution to dependence of Russian gas supplies work? For a good look at the feasibility and cost of a wind/solar generation system without fossil fuel backup, read Mr. Menton’s prior Manhattan Contrarian posts from February 1 here, and January 22 here.

If you’re willing to fight for Main Street America, click here to sign up for the Richardcyoung.com free weekly email.

Related Posts

  • Energy Independence Is a National Security Issue
  • Happy Independence Day!
  • Happy Independence Day!
  • Happy Independence Day!
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Debbie Young
Debbie Young
Debbie, our chief political writer of Richardcyoung.com, is also our chief domestic affairs writer, a contributing writer on Eastern Europe and Paris and Burgundy, France. She has been associate editor of Dick Young’s investment strategy reports for over five decades. Debbie lives in Key West, Florida, and Newport, Rhode Island, and travels extensively in Paris and Burgundy, France, cooking on her AGA Cooker, driving through Vermont and Maine, and practicing yoga. Debbie has completed the 200-hour Krama Yoga teacher training program taught by Master Instructor Ruslan Kleytman. Debbie is a strong supporting member of the NRA.
Debbie Young
Latest posts by Debbie Young (see all)
  • Prostate Screening, an Important, Imperfect Tool - May 22, 2025
  • Salvaging the Unsalvageable - May 21, 2025
  • A Calculated Decision to Keep Silent - May 20, 2025

Dick Young’s Must Reads

  • You Want the Limo, Not the Public Bus
  • Washington Is the Systemic Risk
  • The Government Attack on Americans’ Independence
  • SVB – There’s Panic in the Air
  • Protection While Traveling in France
  • ACTRESS: “Liberal Politicians Are Ruining Cities”
  • Who Will Pay the Price for LEDs?
  • Remembering Brent Scowcroft
  • Biden Wants to Gut the Tax Benefit of 401K Plans
  • Hey, Where’s Everyone Going? Follow the Money Kid

Our Most Popular Posts

  • A Calculated Decision to Keep Silent
  • An American Tragedy
  • Congratulations, You Graduated into Retirement. Now What? #5
  • Retirement #4: How Do You Feel? How Will You Feel?
  • Who Knew about Biden's Health?
  • Middle East Investment Bonanza as Trump Tours Region
  • Donald Trump’s First 100 days
  • Is Trump Divorcing Bibi?
  • A Contemptable Little Twerp
  • PREPARE FOR THE WORST: Poland's Military Overhaul

Compensation was paid to utilize rankings. Click here to read full disclosure.

RSS Youngresearch.com

  • Graduation to Retirement: “I Have a Guy” #7
  • Indonesia Urged to Act Fast to Avert Domestic Gas Crisis by 2033
  • Nuclear Power Gets Green Light in Sweden Despite Political Divide
  • Behind the Code: Microsoft Hunts a Global Cyber Threat
  • Congratulations, You’re Retired: Now What? Part 6
  • U.S. Billionaires Target Congo’s Cobalt in Bid to Secure Energy Future
  • China Dominates Battery Supply Chain: From Mine to Market
  • Shale Plateau Looms as Global LNG Market Set to Double
  • Congratulations, You Graduated into Retirement. Now What? #5
  • World’s Leading EV Motor Factory to Supply Ferrari and Lamborghini

RSS Yoursurvivalguy.com

  • Graduation to Retirement: “I Have a Guy” #7
  • Your Retirement Life: Top of the Rock
  • Where Do We Stand with Tariffs?
  • Congratulations, You’re Retired: Now What? Part 6
  • Investing Habits of the Fairly Wealthy: #10 Powerball
  • Is America Poised for Next Gen Nuclear Power?
  • Congratulations, You Graduated into Retirement. Now What? #5
  • Big Blue Blob Cities Drive Residents (and Money) Away
  • Don’t Forget the Laffer Curve
  • Retirement #4: How Do You Feel? How Will You Feel?

US Treasury Yield Curve: My Favorite Investor Tool

My Key West Garden Office

Your Retirement Life: Traveling the Efficient Frontier

Live a Long Life

Your Survival Guy’s Mt. Rushmore of Investing Legends

“Then One Day the Grandfather was Gone”

Copyright © 2025 | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Dick Young | Archives