Richardcyoung.com

The Online Home of Author and Investor, Dick Young

  • Home
  • How We Are Different
  • About Us
    • Foundation Principles
    • Contributors
  • Investing
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
  • Your Survival Guy
  • The Great Reset
  • COVID-19
  • My Rifles
  • Dividends and Compounding
  • Your Security
  • The Swiss Way
  • Dick Young
  • Debbie Young
  • Key West
  • Paris
  • Dick’s R&B Top 100
  • Liberty & Freedom Map
  • Your Health
  • Ron Paul
  • Bank Credit & Money
  • Dick Young’s Safe America
  • Your Survival Guy’s Super States
  • Critical Race Theory
  • NNT & Cholesterol
  • Work to Make Money/Invest to Save Money

OATH KEEPERS ON TRIAL: Can Government Prosecute Words that it Hates?

January 20, 2022 By The Editors

By Cineberg @ Shutterstock.com

Can the government prosecute the eleven Oath Keepers it claims were conspiring against it simply for the words they said? Judge Andrew Napolitano suggests they cannot, writing:

In 1918, President Woodrow Wilson offered legislation to suppress dissent during World War I, and Congress enacted it. The socialist firebrand Eugene V. Debs was convicted of sedition, a conviction upheld by the Supreme Court, for publicly denouncing the war.

Wilson and his Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer ruthlessly used the Sedition Act of 1918 to suppress dissent. They prosecuted college students who sang German beer hall songs and read the Declaration of Independence aloud in public. Their theory was that dissent dissuaded young men from registering for the draft, and thus had the potential for impairing America’s war effort, and thus constituted sedition.

The statute under which Debs and others were convicted is essentially the same statute under which the Oath Keepers were indicted last week. It also prohibits any conspiracy to overthrow the government by force. A conspiracy is an agreement by two or more persons to commit a crime, where at least one of those persons took a material step in furtherance of the agreement.

But the essence of conspiracy consists of constitutionally protected behavior — speech and thought, and that makes it legally dubious and practically difficult for the government to prove.

The last federal sedition case was brought against a Michigan militia in 2010. The indictment was dismissed by a federal judge who ruled that the defendants’ hateful and threatening words and outlier agreements were protected speech and did not evince a realistic plan to overthrow the government by force.

In the indictment against the Oath Keepers, the feds have outlined in great detail the communications among them in the months preceding Jan. 6. The detail is so great that the FBI must have had an undercover agent or cooperating witness embedded in the group. This leads to a host of other problems for the government. What did the feds know, and when did they know it? How and why did they let it lead to destruction and death?

The Oath Keepers have insisted that they never intended to use violence and only wanted to make a political point — a point that the government hates.

Prosecuting speech is dangerous business. Violence is certainly not constitutionally protected, but hate speech is. As recently as 1969, a unanimous Supreme Court ruled that all innocuous speech is absolutely protected, and all speech is innocuous when there is time for more speech to rebut it.

Even the feds don’t claim that the Oath Keeper defendants are somehow criminally liable for the behavior of others present at the Capitol. Rather, they claim that 11 persons — 11! — agreed to overthrow the government by force. Can an agreement that is impossible to perform legally constitute a conspiracy? Only those who hate the politics of the 11 could seriously believe that it can.

The government should prosecute only crimes that have caused harm, not words and ideas that it hates, for they are protected by the First Amendment that the government has sworn to uphold. Whose words and ideas will the feds prosecute next?

If you’re willing to fight for Main Street America, click here to sign up for the Richardcyoung.com free weekly email.

Related Posts

  • Downsizing Government
  • Angry Words
  • Big Government Bozo
  • Get Government Out of Government
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
The Editors
Latest posts by The Editors (see all)
  • Farmer Tells Steve Bannon Biden’s Inflation Is Ruining His Business - May 23, 2022
  • PARTY’S OVER JOE: Republicans Crush Democrats in Local Elections - May 23, 2022
  • The Destructive Rise and Fall of BLM - May 20, 2022

Dick Young’s Must Reads

  • V4 Stands Against North African and Middle Eastern Invasion
  • 751 “No-Go” Zones in France
  • WAR HAS BEGUN: What Advice Are You Giving Your Loved Ones?
  • Your Survival Guy’s 2022 Super States: #1 New Hampshire
  • Your Sheriff Can Thwart Federal Gun Control Efforts
  • BEYOND RUSSIA: America Strengthens India Ties to Counter China
  • The Armed American Family: Part I
  • Globalism Has Made America Dependent on Foreign Countries
  • The Worst President in American History, Part I
  • The Fed – “Independent” and “Non Political” – Joins The Resistance

Our Most Popular Posts

  • Tucker Carlson Interviews My Favorite Florida Farmer
  • Jean-Pierre: Economy "Not Something that We Keep an Eye on Every Day"
  • What’s Ahead for America During Biden’s Last Years
  • MARKET CHAOS: This May Take Time, Here’s How to Prepare
  • “We Cannot Save Ukraine by Dooming the US Economy.”
  • Consequences of Biden Killing the Keystone Pipeline
  • BE VIGILANT: The Rats Are Scurrying in These Rough Markets
  • Baby Formula Gone Missing?
  • Are You Suffering from One of These Nutrient Deficiencies?
  • PARTY'S OVER JOE: Republicans Crush Democrats in Local Elections

Disclosure

RSS Youngresearch.com

  • Watch Out for Your Worst Enemy
  • Big Banks Adopting Blockchain for Short-Term Trading
  • Job Market Survival Advice for Graduates and for Those YOU Love
  • BULLWHIPPED? Inventory Overhang Could Slow Growth in Certain Sectors
  • BUY THE DIPS? Can You Catch a Ginsu Knife?
  • MARKET TURNING: Canada’s Housing Market Turmoil
  • “I’ve Been with Richard Young for Over 30 Years Now”
  • All-Powerful Money Managers Voting YOUR Money Targeted by Senate GOP
  • HORDING CASH: Funds Hold the Highest Level of Cash Since 9/11
  • COMMODITY CRUNCH: Will Tesla Buy a Cobalt Mine?

The Supreme Court Must Always Protect the Constitution

Our Daily Bread Threatened?

Watch Out for Your Worst Enemy

Farmer Tells Steve Bannon Biden’s Inflation Is Ruining His Business

PARTY’S OVER JOE: Republicans Crush Democrats in Local Elections

Joe Biden – Malicious, Incompetent, a Wannabe Left Wing Ideologue?

Copyright © 2022 | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Dick Young | Archives