Has American Electorate Swung Far to the Left?

By ink drop @Adobe Stock

Nithya Raman won her election in Los Angeles. She joins Janeese Lewis George in Washington and socialist mayors including Zohran Mamdani in New York, Katie Wilson in Seattle, and David Morales in Providence, R.I.

The truth is, writes Mary Julia Koch in The Wall Street Journal, many of the victorious democratic socialists have built big coalitions by cloaking radical policies in the language of moderation and pragmatism.

On Being a Democratic Socialist and a Capitalist

Ms. Raman, for example, attracted disparate factions by downplaying her ties to democratic socialism. How did she wrangle an endorsement from the DSA’s LA chapter? The chapter wasn’t convinced that Ms. Raman was sufficiently outspoken against Israel or dogmatically committed to the party’s agenda. She, though, had no qualms about appearing alongside DSA-aligned influencers, comedians and podcasters. She moderated her stances on practical issues, which appealed to labor unions. Undecided voters and the Democratic establishment aligned with her opponent, Mayor Karen Bass.

Ms. Raman described herself as a “democratic socialist” and a “capitalist.” Her rhetorical straddle employs a strategy to obscure what it means to be a socialist. Most voters struggle to define democratic socialism. Does it mean “Soviet-style collectivism, cold-blooded Maoism, or a Nordic model of cradle-to-grave welfare?” Maybe the confusion is the point, writes Ms.Koch, as confusion ignores specifics and focuses on vibes. As the WSJ article points out: Ms. Raman seems nice; she couldn’t be that crazy.

Centralized Control: Peace, Land, Bread

All politicians alter messages to win elections. Socialism’s history is particularly ugly. Castro hid the ball for politically expedient reasons. During a visit to the US, Fidel Castro publicly denied being a communist. In 1959, he described his political ideals as being a form of “humanism.” In 1961, after the Bay of Pigs, he described himself as a Marxist-Leninist, “explaining he’d previously hid from this label to avoid alienating middle-class allies and the bourgeoisie.”

Vladimir Lenin used the slogan “Peace, Land, and Bread” to build broad public support among the devastated postwar population. His Bolsheviks quickly transitioned from populist promises to centralized control after seizing power in 1917.

These two examples, explains Ms. Koch, are more extreme than anything happening on the ascendant left, yet inspiration seems to be lurking amongst the DSA’s motives.

Could DSA mayors be priming the electorate for the 2028 presidential race? The upcoming 2028 is likely to feature AOC as a candidate for the Democratic nomination. Still, much relies on how the cities the DSA mayors run in the next few years.

As the Journal notes, socialism is being pitched not definitionally but through the pledge of results-oriented governance. The makeover will succeed or fail on a performance basis.

The rising crop of left-wing leaders will have to deliver policy successes if they want voters to believe their promises.

Take Notice

Gina Hinojosa, Texas’s Democratic governor-elect, places herself as a left populist. She rejects the “progressive” label, explaining that progressive is associated with culture wars, and to her, the culture wars are not the 2026 fight.

Yet, Ms. Hinojosa’s track record tells a different story. She’s a member of the Texas Legislative Progressive Caucus, and her voting history in the Texas House puts her among the most liberal Democrats on issues ranging from universal healthcare to environmental policy.

Previous articleWhen Flight Isn’t an Option
Debbie Young
Debbie, our chief political writer at Richardcyoung.com, is also our chief domestic affairs writer, a contributing writer on Eastern Europe and Paris and Burgundy, France. She has been associate editor of Dick Young’s investment strategy reports for over five decades. Debbie lives in Key West, Florida, and Newport, Rhode Island, and travels extensively in Paris and Burgundy, France, cooking on her AGA Cooker, and practicing yoga. Debbie has completed the 200-hour Krama Yoga teacher training program taught by Master Instructor Ruslan Kleytman. Debbie is a strong supporting member of the NRA.