Richardcyoung.com

The Online Home of Author and Investor, Dick Young

  • Home
  • How We Are Different
  • About Us
    • Foundation Principles
    • Contributors
  • Investing
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
  • Your Survival Guy
  • The Great Reset
  • COVID-19
  • My Rifles
  • Dividends and Compounding
  • Your Security
  • The Swiss Way
  • Dick Young
  • Debbie Young
  • Key West
  • Paris
  • Dick’s R&B Top 100
  • Liberty & Freedom Map
  • Your Health
  • Ron Paul
  • Bank Credit & Money
  • Dick Young’s Safe America
  • Your Survival Guy’s Super States
  • Critical Race Theory
  • NNT & Cholesterol
  • Work to Make Money/Invest to Save Money

Notre Dame Not the Arena for Idiosyncratic Personal Expression

May 3, 2019 By Debbie Young

By Martina Badini @ Shutterstock.com

“It’s complicated,” said our driver more than once, as we discussed different issues – the Gilets Jaunes, Notre Dame, the bitter reaction to philanthropic giving from France’s wealthiest citizens.

It took only two days after Notre Dame’s flames had been extinguished for President Macron to announce that France’s greatest gothic cathedral would be rebuilt in only five years, adding, oddly, that it would be “even more beautiful.”

Neither a five-year timeframe nor “even more beautiful” is likely to happen, writes Michael Lewis in the WSJ.

Mr. Lewis senses danger now that the restoration after the fire is in the hands of bureaucrats. Also making him uneasy is, in the desperate scramble to keep these two promises, much might go awry. “What happens now might well be more destructive, and less reversible, than the events of April 15.”

Many who watched the lofty central spire fall into the flames assumed that the building was a total loss. But the cathedral consists of two virtually independent structures, a timber-framed roof above and a sturdy shell of space beneath, enclosed entirely in robust stone. Its masonry vaults might have passed through the fire unscathed had the collapsing spire not plunged through the vault below.

All this can be repaired, the fallen vaults rebuilt, the mighty roof truss replaced. The key question is the straightforward one of whether the great roof truss is to be reconstructed in oak or steel. The wood trusses of the burned out churches of World War II were often succeeded by steel ones, while more recently the roof of England’s York Minster was replaced in timber after it was struck by lightning in 1984 and set aflame.

Enter Architecture’s Ambulance Chasers

But the French government has opted for spectacle over restraint. There is to be an architectural competition, not only to replace the roof, but to give us a spire, as Prime Minister Édouard Philippe put it, “suited to the techniques and challenges of our time.”

Not surprising in today’s age of technology, the internet quickly became awash with jaunty designs for the spire: a spire of light, a vertical apiary for bees inhabiting the roof of Notre Dame, a frozen sculpture of the fire itself, “offensively memorialized in gold leaf.”

What is common to all of them is that they were conceived on the computer monitor and are meant to be seen in the same way. But the visual language of the small screen has its own distorting logic. As in Pop Art, large exaggerated shapes and instantly recognizable forms carry well, and caricature is rewarded.

Currently the restoration of Notre Dame is treating the restoration as an administrative affair under the control of Gen. Jean-Louis Georgelin, a former army chief of staff.

Competitions, alas, are not won by displays of quiet probity. But historic restoration succeeds or fails by the specific treatment of specific physical materials. The French track record in this area has not been good. The restoration of Chartres Cathedral has been a catastrophe. Having never previously been thoroughly restored it had a gloriously palpable sense of ancientness; it now feels like a facsimile of the original building, re-created at one-to-one scale.

The Spire – One of the Most Inspired Creations of Gothic Revival

Eugène-Emmanuel Viollet-le-Duc (1814-1879) left his mark on the cathedral when he added its 19th-century spire; is our century not also entitled to leave its mark? But this is to misunderstand Viollet-le-Duc, whose spire was anything but a personal statement. It rested on a stupendous knowledge of the history and variety of Gothic architecture, and is one of the most inspired creations of the Gothic Revival. His majestic nine-volume dictionary of medieval French architecture has a 46-page article on the subject of crossing spires, for which there is no good English word; the French term is flèche, or arrow. The article concludes with a brilliant analysis of his new flèche for Notre Dame, making it the definitive flèche.

Notre Dame’s Spirit of Rational Materialism

A Gothic cathedral is a collective achievement, the outcome of countless craftsmen working across the centuries toward a common goal; it is not the arena for idiosyncratic personal expression.

Of course, in the end Viollet-le-Duc did leave the mark of the 19th century on Notre Dame, above all its spirit of rational materialism, but he did so inadvertently, as the indirect byproduct of his scrupulous pursuit of excellence.

We will also leave our signature on the building, whether we want to or not, but it should not be the self-consciously contemporary signature of a celebrity architect, seeing in the ashes a chance for a star turn.

Complicated, indeed.

Read more here.

If you’re willing to fight for Main Street America, click here to sign up for the Richardcyoung.com free weekly email.

Related Posts

  • Notre Dame in Flames
  • Notre Dame, the Nucleus of Paris
  • Paris Update: Notre-Dame, Protests and Your Survival Guy
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Debbie Young
Debbie, editor-in-chief of Richardcyoung.com, has been associate editor of Dick Young’s investment strategy reports for over three decades. When not in Key West, Debbie spends her free time researching and writing in and about Paris and Burgundy, France, cooking on her AGA Cooker, driving her Porsche Boxter S through Vermont and Maine, and practicing yoga.
Latest posts by Debbie Young (see all)
  • What Would We Do without the Experts? - May 19, 2022
  • Florida: Enjoy Certain Freedoms and Individual Liberties - May 19, 2022
  • Consequences of Biden Killing the Keystone Pipeline - May 18, 2022

Dick Young’s Must Reads

  • America’s Colleges Have Become Progressive Liberal Rat Holes
  • CONSTITUTIONAL CARRY: Alabama Becomes 22nd Permitless Carry State
  • Warning! Your Survival Guy’s on a Boil Water Advisory
  • Protection While Traveling in France
  • Stunned Democrats Against “Defund Police”
  • Boom—Your Life Changes
  • We’ll Burn the Place Down!
  • Your Best State on Guns, Plus the 8th Wonder of the World
  • “I’ve Got Guys Buying Guns/Ammo for Me All Through the Night.”
  • TROJAN HORSE: “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion” is Critical Race Theory in Disguise

Our Most Popular Posts

  • Tucker Carlson Interviews My Favorite Florida Farmer
  • What’s Ahead for America During Biden’s Last Years
  • MARKET CHAOS: This May Take Time, Here’s How to Prepare
  • “We Cannot Save Ukraine by Dooming the US Economy.”
  • Baby Formula Gone Missing?
  • BE VIGILANT: The Rats Are Scurrying in These Rough Markets
  • PRICES SOAR: Diesel Shortage Could Cripple America's Economy
  • Biden: A National Disgrace
  • WATCHING YOU: Italy Deploys Stealth Social Credit System
  • BUSTED BUDGETS: Families Can't Afford Democrats' Anti-Energy Regulations

Disclosure

RSS Youngresearch.com

  • BUY THE DIPS? Can You Catch a Ginsu Knife?
  • MARKET TURNING: Canada’s Housing Market Turmoil
  • “I’ve Been with Richard Young for 30 Years”
  • All-Powerful Money Managers Voting YOUR Money Targeted by Senate GOP
  • HORDING CASH: Funds Hold the Highest Level of Cash Since 9/11
  • COMMODITY CRUNCH: Will Tesla Buy a Cobalt Mine?
  • Young Americans Fall in Love with Farming, Again
  • Your Survival Guy: “Sell in May, Buy After Labor Day?”
  • China’s Economy Taking Hit from Zero-COVID Strategy
  • Is Your Financial Advisor Hiding the Truth About ESG?

What Would We Do without the Experts?

V4 Stands Against North African and Middle Eastern Invasion

BUY THE DIPS? Can You Catch a Ginsu Knife?

Florida: Enjoy Certain Freedoms and Individual Liberties

ENERGY FREEDOM ACT: Ted Cruz Introduces Bill for Energy Independence

Consequences of Biden Killing the Keystone Pipeline

Copyright © 2022 | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Dick Young | Archives