Richardcyoung.com

The Online Home of Author and Investor, Dick Young

  • Home
  • How We Are Different
  • About Us
    • Foundation Principles
    • Contributors
  • Investing
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
  • Your Survival Guy
  • The Great Reset
  • COVID-19
  • My Rifles
  • Concentrate on Dividend Record and Compounding
  • Your Security
  • The Swiss Way
  • Dick Young
  • Debbie Young
  • Key West
  • Paris
  • Dick’s R&B Top 100
  • Liberty & Freedom Map
  • Your Health
  • Ron Paul
  • Bank Credit & Money
  • Freedom Force
  • Dick Young’s Safe America
  • Bank for International Settlements

Is Tribalism All That Bad?

July 27, 2018 By Debbie Young

Debbie Young

In a lengthy article in The American Conservative, Matt Purple, managing editor, discusses innocuous tribalism and puzzles over why it can’t coexist with liberalism. When rooting for the New England Patriots or defending America to skeptical foreigners, Matt Purple admits that he is indulging his own inner tribalism in that he is irrationally siding with groups into which he was born.

In reflecting on tribalism, he uses national identity as an example:

The country in which one is raised, the language one is schooled to speak, the historical figures one learns to venerate, the customs that order one’s life. Intensify this pride too much and shades of World War II appear, but in smaller doses—cheering on Team USA in the World Cup, for example—it is surely benign and even healthy.

It isn’t clear why this innocuous tribalism can’t coexist with liberalism. In fact, it seems to me that the grievance of most populist voters isn’t against liberal rights; it’s that liberalism has become a misnomer for a mutant ideology that seeks to erase those borders, shred those flags, silence those anthems, block (or at least reroute) those harmless conduits of tribalism.

Certainly the European Union wants this; its leaders have said so outright. As classical liberalism is concerned, this is more a matter of geography than substance.

People want to live freely, but to be governed from home and by their fellow countrymen.

In addition to being tribalist, man is also communal, desiring a social order in which he has a comfortable place, in need of institutions warmer and more intimate than the faceless state.

Moving on to Erich Fromm, Mr. Purple writes about Fromm’s 1941 book, Escape From Freedom, in which Fromm psychoanalyzes Germany under Nazi rule. Fromm worried that freedom had the negative effect of making man “isolated and, thereby, anxious and powerless.”

For Fromm, capitalism, though it freed man to pursue his ambitions, removed him from the structured security that was provided by the guilds and stable small economies of the Middle Ages. This left him feeling alienated and increasingly separated from the products of his own hands (a concern that’s haunted philosophers from Marx to Deneen). It also created economic entities that dwarfed him—jobs where management is distant, large department stores that make shopping impersonal, national political parties that don’t speak to his problems. This loneliness and smallness makes him long for a warm place in a more visceral hierarchy—enter the National Socialists.

The trends that vexed Fromm have only accelerated today, as Christmas presents are purchased from gigantic retailers at the click of a mouse and corporate buyouts darken the skies above small businesses. Such consolidation is not the whole story of American capitalism, but it is a consequence of a globalized world where multinationals sprawl across borders. Both the Trump revolt and the Left’s identity politics can be understood in part as structures of resistance against these behemoth institutions.

(A)nyone who’s ever lived in Washington knows that “tribal” is a good way to describe federal workers who are more likely to pursue their own interests than set about implementing anyone’s conception of the common good.

Still, these two realities—the harmlessness (even healthfulness) of some tribal nationalism and the impersonality of today’s mammoth institutions—are too easily dismissed by elites, which is one reason the populist wave continues to deluge capitals. That populism, whatever you think of it, is responding to something real and malignant, something that could be attributed to the excesses of globalist, capitalist liberalism.

Read more from Matt Purple here.

Related Posts

  • Bad Journalism, Bad Form, Bad Manners.
  • Remembering Breaking Bad With Badfinger
  • Breaking Bad, Breaking Good
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Debbie Young
Debbie, editor-in-chief of Richardcyoung.com, has been associate editor of Dick Young’s investment strategy reports for over three decades. When not in Key West, Debbie spends her free time researching and writing in and about Paris and Burgundy, France, cooking on her AGA Cooker, driving her Porsche Boxter S through Vermont and Maine, and practicing yoga.
Latest posts by Debbie Young (see all)
  • A Pitiful, Helpless Giant? - April 15, 2021
  • COVID Mask Wearing Buffoonery - April 14, 2021
  • Law and Order – A Twisted Joke - April 14, 2021

Dick Young’s Must Reads

  • 751 “No-Go” Zones in France
  • Soros’s Open Society Foundation, Charles Koch Team Up
  • Being Fully American Means Americans First
  • “I’ve Got Guys Buying Guns/Ammo for Me All Through the Night.”
  • What to Do about China?
  • To Me There Isn’t a Better Way to Live
  • Globalism Has Made America Dependent on Foreign Countries
  • Richard Feynman Solved the Space Shuttle Disaster Mystery
  • Blue Dog Democrats Must Stop the Squad’s Assault on America
  • The Common Ground of Democracy is Sinking Beneath Americans’ Feet

Our Most Popular Posts

  • What's the Best Survival Currency?
  • Former Pfizer VP Blows the Whistle on COVID Mortality Rate Scam
  • One Word Explains the Worth of Your Neighbors’ House
  • Boycott Corporate Cancel Culture
  • Move from Mass., Conn., Vermont, Maine to New Hampshire
  • Gold’s 50-Year Price Explosion
  • RECONSTRUCTION: The Confiscation of All His Property
  • How About Giving North Conway, NH a Visit?
  • CBS – Picking on the Ron Guy
  • Demography Is Destiny: You Will Rise and Stand

Disclosure

RSS Youngresearch.com

  • Crushing Words to Avoid: “We’re Disappointed in You”
  • How Amazon Violates Anti-Trust Rules
  • Why Service Is King in 1(800)# Teenage Wasteland
  • Long Live the Dividend King
  • Your Port Against a Storm.
  • Inflation? Yes.
  • Banks Prepare for Boom
  • Fidelity Investments #1: Hires 4,000 Focuses on YOU
  • Larry Summers: Stimulus “Substantially Excessive”
  • It’s as Simple as 4%? No, Not Anymore

The Vanguard Wellesley Way

Toilet Paper and SPAM: What More You Can Do?

The Government Cannot Constitutionally Interfere With Gun Ownership

A Pitiful, Helpless Giant?

What Happens When Even Logic and Facts Can’t Persuade the Left?

Don’t Miss the Boat: Meet Your Money Stewards

Copyright © 2021 | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Dick Young | Archives